HomeItalySerie A

Restructuring Milan: Who to Keep, Who to Sell & Who to Buy

Restructuring Milan: Who to Keep, Who to Sell & Who to Buy

In his first column WFI’s Calcio Consultant Frank Crivello assesses the AC Milan squad and looks at potential signings for the club this summer.

I’m not much for cheesy introductions. You’ll learn about me as I blog and offer my opinion on various topics regarding the Italian game.

I’m the host of Serie A Sitdown on World Football Index, and have been a faithful Milan supporter for 30 years. Yep, pretty much since Silvio Berlusconi took ownership of the Rossoneri.

I’ve suffered the last several years as have all Milanisti, a decade of gradual decline from Kings of Europe to flirting with football obscurity. The recent 4-1 battering taken at home to Roma is all the evidence one needs.

Embed from Getty Images


The 2016-2017 version of AC Milan has been akin to drinking coffee; sure you’re bouncing with enthusiasm and get spurts of energy, but the crash is inevitably coming.

The squad is one that obviously has been watered down, basically in preparation for a change in ownership.

Yonghong Li and Rossoneri Sport Luxembourg have taken over, and have big plans to bring AC Milan to the forefront of World Football again.

Embed from Getty Images


All new owners say that though, don’t they? They clearly won’t be able to overhaul 20-25 players in the summer to help make this happen, much to the chagrin of Milan supporters who think that can actually happen.

So I’m here to help Mr Li, Mr Marco Fassone, and Mr Massimo Mirabelli. Let’s start with the current squad, who stays and who should move.


Gianluigi Donnarumma (keep), Alessandro Plizzari (loan out), Marco Storari (keep)

Embed from Getty Images


The new owners need a face of the team. Much like Paolo Maldini had been the face of Milan throughout most of Berlusconi’s regime.

Donnarumma should be the face of this one, and there just isn’t another option.

Priority one for Fassone and co is to lock the wonderkid up for several years and have an expensive out clause. That’s the obvious part.

Plizzari is another teenager brought up through the Milan youth system, loan him out and get him experience.

Marco Storari is 40, and my most vivid memory of him as a Milan ‘keeper was the 4-0 beating he took in the Derby to Inter in 2009. That, and the awful first half campaign for Cagliari this season. His contract expires at the end of June, but keep him on for another year as the third choice.

If you’re going to have a third choice, no shame in having someone who can mentor Donnarumma on the professional aspects of being a goalkeeper (just don’t show him tape of that 2009 Derby or any of his time at Cagliari).

Bring Gabriel back from his loan spell at Cagliari and have him be the number two next season.

Donnarumma is the guy, and only an injury (heaven forbid) is going to keep him out.


Keep: Ignazio Abate, Luca Antonelli, Mattia De Sciglio, Gustavo Gomez, Alessio Romagnoli, and Leonel Vangioni.

Loan out: Davide Calabria.

Move on: from Gabriel Paletta and Christian Zapata.

Embed from Getty Images


Abate and Anotnelli have been long-term injury casualties this season, but are veteran players who can come in and spot start here and there.

Full back needs an upgrade, but a lot of teams will be saying that. Where is De Sciglio’s head? Does he really want to move?

The fact he’s been captain in some games are signs that Milan trust the leader he is becoming. If there is money to spend this summer, De Sciglio can be the starting right back and a left back will be purchased.

Gustavo Gomez is raw, and needs time to adapt to the Italian game, a little unfair to write him off after one season.

Same with Vangioni, who when given the chance started great but since has been putrid (recent performance against Roma will be most forgettable).

These are reserves that should get one more season to prove themselves. Alessio Romagnoli has shown this season he is a rising star and, with Donnarumma, part of the foundation for the new Milan.

Calabria is just not ready yet, Ivan Perisic toyed with him in the most recent Derby. Let him get games somewhere else.

Gabriel Paletta has proven time and again that he is a red card waiting to happen. Milan should move on from him, but will probably have to keep him as he has one more year left on his current deal and no one will want him.

For the sake of this blog, I’m wishing they’ll release him.

As for Zapata, he relies on his pace to make up for his lack of positioning, and now that he’s on the wrong side of 30 that pace won’t be there much longer.

He’s got two more years on his contract, a promoted side in Serie A or another league would be willing to gamble on him. If an offer comes, make the move.


Keep: Andrea Bertolacci, Giacomo Bonaventura, Manuel Locatelli, Riccardo Montolivo, Mario Pasalic, Andrea Poli, Jose Sosa.

Move on: from Mati Fernandez, Keisuke Honda, Juraj Kucka.

Embed from Getty Images


Bertolacci showed his talent at Genoa before arriving at Milan and injuries have played a part in keeping him out. Milan spent on him, so I think he’ll get the chance to prove himself.

Bonaventura has proven his quality since arriving from Atalanta, his injury has certainly played a part in Milan’s stagnancy down the stretch this season.

Manuel Locatelli is one for the future, has played well when given the chance, and puzzles me why he’s not been getting a run out of late.

I have been a big critic of Montolivo (most Milanisti have), but events since his injury show the respect he has from his peers as captain. He could be the new Massimo Ambrosini in which he is captain by title but a squad rotation player when it comes to team selection.

I thought I read that Milan don’t plan to keep their loanees. If they keep one it should be Pasalic. He gets the yips in big games but he’s also only 22 and the talent is there for him to be a key player.

Poli is a squad guy who gives his all when given the chance. He has one year left on his contract anyway so keep him on as a rotation player, and move on from him next year.

Sosa is another veteran who has put in some decent performances, but another that is in no way a regular first teamer at this stage of his career. Not where Milan want to go. Don’t need to move on from him, but let him play out the final year of his deal.

Fernandez is a loan signing and has spent more time on the treatment table than on the pitch. He’s not worth having long term.

Honda never worked out, his contract is up at the end of this season, and there’s talk of him going to MLS anyway.

Kucka is decent box to box guy, but also 30 and has a habit of being a bit reckless. He has two years left on his contract, and a middling to relegation-fighting top flight team may be willing to take a chance on him.


Keep: Ginaluca Lapadula and Suso.

Loan out: Patrick Cutrone.

Move on: from Carlos Bacca, Gerard Deulofeu, and Lucas Ocampos.

Embed from Getty Images


This may be the section where I get some flack, so what, it’s my blog!

Lapadula was brought in this season and his results, cult figure or not, have been mixed. With a couple of the names being bounced about for striker at Milan, he can be a rotation player and a useful one.

Suso has been consistent as he goes, the Milan attack goes. He’s starting to prove the quality that attracted him to the likes of Liverpool as a youth player.

Out of the six attackers in the current team, these are the only two I would keep.

Cutrone is a product of the Milan youth system and could afford to get experience elsewhere.

Bacca has been pretty good for Milan overall, but in recent games he looks like he’s running in cement boots.

Striker is a glaring need for this Milan team, especially considering all the teams at the top with players who are in the thick of this season’s Capocannoniere race.

Does Bacca want to stay? Will he be forced out? He’s 31 and has three years left on his contract, not sure who would want to buy that out.

Deulofeu started his loan spell brightly but honestly, he has tapered off. He’s all dribbling and pace, not much beyond that.

Ocampos has a lot to give yet as he is only 22, but that has been said about him since he was at Monaco.

Deulofeu and Ocampos are both on loan, and I don’t see either staying beyond their spell.

Embed from Getty Images


Okay, so 10 new players after doing all of this, replacing 7 permanent and 3 loaned out.

Goalkeeper is easy, if Plizzari is to be loaned out then Gabriel can return from his loan and be the number two. Better than having him rot the bench at Cagliari.

After that, two other players on loan could rejoin the team next season.

First is Gianmarco Zigoni, a forward who is having a successful loan spell at Spal, scoring 9 times in 34 appearances. With so many attacking players being linked, Zigoni can be relied on for squad depth.

Also for depth, Jose Mauri can be recalled and kept. He’s a young midfielder who has only made 14 appearances on loan with Empoli.

That means Milan will have to buy at least seven players.

Here would be seven players to add to the team. Each have been linked in some shape, form or fashion:

  • Mateo Musacchio: Villarreal man has been linked to the San Siro before, he and Romagnoli in the heart of the defense would be a nice pairing.
  • Stefan De Vrij: His name has come up, would be another center back for Milan but I would be surprised if he joined. Let’s say he does. Milan have a nice rotation of center backs with Musacchio, De Vrij and Romagnoli.
  • Ricardo Rodriguez: Being heavily linked recently, the Swiss international is at Wolfsburg, would immediately upgrade Milan at left back and move De Sciglio to the right. It’s been rumored there is a verbal agreement between his camp and Milan.
  • Luis Gustavo: The Brazilian international is also linked, his contract is up in June 2018 and can be bought for a bargain. Solid box to box midfielder.
  • Franck Kessie: The Ivorian was set for Roma but stories are he’s done an about face and wants to join Milan.
  • Alejandro “Papu” Gomez: Has been the creative engine for Atalanta’s surprise run to the Europa League this season. Mirabelli is believed to be very interested in him.
  • Alvaro Morata or Andrea Belotti: Milan NEED a striker with 25+ goal potential. Carlos Bacca just can’t do it anymore. Morata has Serie A experience from his time at Juventus and is capable of such goal upside.The Italian in me prefers Belotti, believed to be a Milan fan. It would be interesting if the new Milan Brass can pull that off. Story is that Torino officials did meet with Mirabelli and Han Li this week.
Embed from Getty Images


Other names that have been tossed around are Pierre Emerick-Aubameyang, Nikola Kalinic, and Keita Balde.

Any of them would be improvements to the attack as well, but it appears Mirabelli, Fassone, and co have their sights set on some of the players above.

This would create a Milan that can being taking the steps toward being among the best on the continent. But what about…


Vicenzo Montella

Embed from Getty Images


Montella was tasked with taking a patched together team and getting it to overachieve.

With three Serie A games remaining at the time of writing, he is achieving the objective of reaching next season’s Europa League.

He has done wonders with what he has at his disposal, as he has wherever he’s gone. Whether Milan see out 6th or not, Montella has earned the opportunity to work with a strengthened squad.

Embed from Getty Images


This would be a reasonable restructuring of Milan without completely overhauling the squad.

It would be a Milan squad deep enough and good enough to handle the workload of competing in Serie A, Coppa Italia, and Europa League.

Maybe, just maybe, the genesis of a new period of greatness at Milanello.


  • comment-avatar

    Great article. I’ve been a Milan fan for about as long as you, I think. Since I was playing “soccer” as a child.

    I agree with most of your assessments. Hopefully Mirabelli and Fassone have some negotiating skills and and acquire players in spite of no Champions League.

  • comment-avatar
    Rasheed 6 years ago

    I totally agree with you on this, I hope your article gets to the office of Mr fassone and co… thanks so much

  • comment-avatar
    Rasheed 6 years ago

    sorry for not introducing my self, my name is Rasheed from Nigeria and I’ve being a Milan fan since 5years old and I av bbreath Milan for 21 years now I just can’t do without ac Milan football club, Milan is my life. Forza!!! Milano

  • comment-avatar
    besart 6 years ago

    I am sorry, but I do not agree with most of your opinion. Why keep Montolivo? He is just slowing the game and does nothing else. With Abate you can’t be a contender in CHL. Bertolacci simply sucks, so does Poli. Why do you need Poli when he just runs around and produces nothing at all. We need class midfielders, left and right backs. In order to use Bacca to his full potential, you need to feed him with good crosses, use him exactly as we used Inzaghi…

    • comment-avatar

      Thanks for your comment. I agree with your evaluation of each of those players. However, this isn’t like playing FIFA or Football Manager where you can overhaul a squad. Montolivo is a leader in the dressing room, evidenced by some of the demonstrations of the players after his injury. Read my take again, he can be captain in title, but in the Ambrosini sense where he’s a rotation player. I’m not giving up on Bertolacci, injuries have plagued him. In the end he may be a better player for a provincial team (see Borriello) but Milan invested a lot in him. They’ll try and make it work. Poli? He has one year left after this. No one will pay for him to run around and do nothing, as you say. Let him play out his contract and he can move on for free.

      • comment-avatar
        besart 6 years ago

        Well, you are right, but the problem has to be solved in 2 years, 3 at the latest. That is why I think that in the next teansfer window Milan has to do as much “cleansing” as possible. My opinion is to sell Poli even for 2 million and invest in a youngster from Primavera. One of the main problems in Milan is the “psychological training” (thats what I call it), the players have absolutely no clue what AC Milan is, it seems like they are there only to do their jobs and get paid, they kind of don’t love the Club abd that hurts me and the club. Someone should give lessons to the players on the value of the club…

  • comment-avatar
    O'Gabbs 6 years ago

    Nice article

  • comment-avatar
    Micheal 6 years ago

    love the article,its a gud selection n I will go wit som of ur options but nt all.in my own opinion I really think we just nid established players in the serie a..that bein said,this r my recommendations:-Morata(he knows d league already)Beradi frm sassuolo..frank kesie frm atalanta(correct me if m wrong),koulibaly frm napoli,papu gomez,baselli frm torino,den if we can kip de sciglio it will b lyk a new signing cos I rili think he’s nt willin to stay put at milan..n yea we nid new n gud rb n lb bt I dnt knw of any tho…Forza Milan!

  • comment-avatar
    Nesta 6 years ago

    Yes i do agree with you but i just wanna say something. I have been a fun for this club for so many years and am hurt that AC Milan is not playing any major competitions this time around.. First I will say something about Montela, I will blame him for all the loose that we played for some games. How can Roma beat us 1-4 ? That impossible!! .. Benching Lucatteli doesn’t make sense to the club. Also there is no need to sell Carlos Bacca, we need to find a critical midfielder who can link good passes football. The coach doesn’t have his first 11 man squad and that is hurting.. Please keep Jura kuca for the club … Please new management who is now on board, buy UCL players not players that entertain us.. Also keep Gustavo Gomez please!! Don’t sell him !!! .. Thanks

  • comment-avatar
    Ahmad A Y A 6 years ago

    Thank you mr calcio consultan about preparation but i think selling kucka and keeping poli or batolacci is a very mistake in my opinion

  • comment-avatar
    Robert 6 years ago

    My opinion is devrig, mateo richardo and continue for defense, kessie and beresi for midfield, beradi and keita and beloti as forwards. We should play a 3-5-2 next season, our problem this season has been defense and the porous midfield .Robert from Uganda.

  • comment-avatar
    OGUNGBEMI MAYOWA 6 years ago

    My name is mayor,but wit d love of d introduction of Brazilians skillful players in 2008,kaka,ronaldinho and pato,I choose to be called mayorpato.i am a full fans of acmilan,a well devoted one.my suggestions on dis Milan team is a total recruitment, I:e only few players are to stay,donarumma,romagnoli,vangioni,de scigle,abate,montolivo,pasalic,lucatelli,kucka,suso,bonaventura,lapadula…..so we need musachio,rodrigues,kjear,de vrij,fabregas,kessie,pjanic,keita balde,a gomez,insegne,morata,…. As for d coach,montella as done is part,acmilan is too big for im,we need a cup winner coach not Europa league qualifier…..m allegri,r Mancini,l blanc,c anceloti.

  • comment-avatar
    Abdullahi Sabo 6 years ago

    I totally submit to the first write up made by,BESART.A fan from Nigeria. Abdullahi are my Names.

  • comment-avatar
    Kingsley,a.k.a,Kingkong. 6 years ago

    I’m kingsley residing in Northampton-Britain.I have been being a Milan supporter since 1988.I eat AC MILAN and do sleep with MILAN.I am writing to suggest some salient points that could turn things around for my mother club,AC MILAN.They are not far fetched;1.we need two strong central defenders plus a powerful left back like Maldini with De Scieglio being at the right full back,2.we need a registrar like Perlo,a ball joggler and schemer like Seedorf and a no non-sense destroyer like Gattuso at the midfield,3.Upfront we would need prolific and versatile bomber like Weah and Shevchenko,4.we need super substitutions.Galliani and Allegri made a big mistake by letting go ALL the experience players at our disposal that time frame within a year,no no no,what!5,We need a winning Coach like Fabio Capello to reconstruct the team.Mirrabelli and Fassone must go for the quality and not quantity of players.To say the least however,the dressing room leadership and spirit has also dwindled.

  • comment-avatar
    sulaiman Aliyu 6 years ago

    thanks i read this articul i have been a milan fan since 89/90 back to back i really lov milan and name is sulaiman from nigeria my advice is to send montela out of d team bcs we will nt achiev anything from him is too small 4 milan find anoder big coach pls like regcard mancini pigrini forza milan d pride ofitalian teams

  • comment-avatar

    Nice article. I dont agree with everything, but overall I think your mostly right in your assesments. Just wondering, how would you set up your preferred starting eleven with this squad?

    • comment-avatar

      Hi Sven, thanks for your comments! Here is how I would make it work:

      Goalkeeper: Donnarumma

      Back four: De Sciglio, Musacchio, Romagnoli, Rodriguez

      Midfield: Kessie, Luis Gustavo, Locatelli

      Forwards: Suso, Belotti, Bonaventura